Hello Kirk,
Since you are able to check the email messages on the server (hotmail) there could be other reasons why they cannot be downloaded my MSN.
Go to the email page and check if you only have 1 Inbox. If there are others, please follow these steps to remove additional email accounts which maybe causing the concern:
1. Click on Help & Settings at the top then click Settings.
2. Click "1 Change your e-mail settings"
3. Click "Additional e-mail accounts"
4. Click "Additional MSN and Hotmail e-mail accounts"
5. Select the account you want to remove then click the Remove Account button.
6. Click Yes to confirm
7. Click Save Changes
8. Click Done
9. Click the Mail&More icon at the top to go back to the email page
10 The additional email account should no longer be on the email page.
Not having the latest version of MSN can also cause the email messages not to be downloaded from the email servers. You should have MSN 10.2. To check the MSN Version, click Help and Settings at the top then About MSN.
If you don’t have MSN 10.2, please follow the steps that are marked in green on this link to remove the old MSN and install the latest one:
http://answers.msn.com/thread.aspx?threadid=9d4183d7-f422-4c12-84f4-4dd35f8e2ac1
If you already have MSN 10.2, we’ll need to use the email synchronization tool that our Product Engineers developed.
Before you use this tool, please back up email messages saved under Folders on your Computer since you will lose them otherwise. Please follow Method 1 on this link: http://answers.msn.com/solution.aspx?solutionid=d830f08c-414d-49ae-91cb-df58aa44832f.
If you are doing this process on several e-mail accounts, please change the last part of the file name so that you can identify the exported email. For example, instead of leaving it as MSN_Mail.msnbak you can change it to MSN_(e-mail address).msnbak.
Please check the Private Message area below for further information.
Feel free to reply to this post for any questions and feedback.
Thanks!
Isabelle